I had voted for them last year. Do I think that they deserve to be inducted? Absolutely.

Did they really precede The Moody Blues as a co-founder of Progressive rock?

Or did they more or less, invent this genre at about the same time as others, namely Jefferson Airplane and The Moody Blues?

Posted by Enigmaticus on Friday, 11/29/2013 @ 07:45am

Forty six years ago, something amazing had happened. Rock groups had decided to incorporate new influences into their music. Whether or not, this revolution was sparked by the ingestion of L.S.D. Is entirely speculative.

Procol Harum had released a hit single, 'A Whiter Shade Of Pale,' based upon a work by Johann Sebastian Bach, much to the chagrin of critics who had felt that this incorporation of Baroque, Classical and Romantic styles was a betrayal to the roots of rock & roll. After all, did not Chuck Berry sing a song entitled, 'Roll Over Beethoven?'

However, "progressive rock" was born, and regardless of whether or not, the critics wanted to wish it away; it was here to stay. At around the same time, The Moody Blues had been working on their stage show, Grace Slick had joined Jefferson Airplane, The Beatles were recording "Sergeant Pepper's Lonely Heart's Club Band," Frank Zappa and The Mothers Of Invention were doing their thing and The Nice was just starting out, so there was a great deal of musical innovation occurring at this time.

Even so, Procol Harum was constantly innovating. Gary Brooker had that remarkable soulful voice, Robin Trower's guitar work was phenomenal, Keith Reid's surrealistic lyrics were mind expanding and Matthew Fisher's Hammond Organ was ethereal.

Procol Harum had been nominated for induction into the Rock & Roll Hall Of Fame back in October, 2012; this was only 20 years later than when they were first eligible. In my honest opinion, Procol Harum does indeed deserve induction for writing so many great songs and for having the chutzpah to do what they wanted to do, as such, their work was revolutionary and deserves to be acknowledged accordingly. Of course, out of the 15 nominees for induction last year, I had chosen the following 5 artists: Rush, Heart, Donna Summer, Randy Newman and Procol Harum.

Posted by Enigmaticus on Friday, 12/27/2013 @ 11:33am

I think it's possible Procol Harum receives a 2015 Nomination and 2016 Induction. They fit some of the coveted slots as they originated in the 60's and early prog. A Procol Harum selection would be smart. Many of the FRL fans have Moody Blues or YES receiving prog slot but Procol Harum might be the choice. A Whiter Shade of Pale definitely a Classic song and one of the best ever. It helps that some of the Procol Harum members are still alive in late 60's now early 70's. They will be able to receive their induction. Listened to Salty Dog last night. Excellent song! I would vote for Procol Harum if nominated on the RRHOF fan ballot. KING

Posted by KING on Saturday, 09/12/2015 @ 19:11pm

I see some similarities with Procol Harum and Deep Purple. Both were leaders and originators in their music fields. Procol Harum-Progressive Rock & Deep Purple-Heavy Rock/Metal. Originated around the same time 1967 & 1968. Both groups had excellent musicians on all their instruments & had important classic songs. They went on hiatus around the same time. 1976-1977 time frame. Deep Purple & Chicago's 2016 induction should help Procol Harum move to the top of the snub list and land a 60's group slot on the ballot. I guess The Zombies, Moody Blues, Procol Harum would be 3 of the best bets to find a way on the ballot from the 60's groups. Tommy James & The Shondells too. KING

Posted by KING on Thursday, 12/24/2015 @ 17:10pm

Procol Harum was nominated once before but they should have been inducted years ago. The Prog Rock Genre has trouble getting inducted. I find that strange since many of the great inducted artists are from the 70's time frame. They might have even played gigs with these groups. A Whiter Shade Of Pale is a Classic song. The catalogue of Procol Harum songs is rich and outstanding. Crucifiction Lane, A Salty Dog, Conquistador,Pandora's Box to name a few. Many of the Procol Harum group are still alive and deserve induction. KING

Posted by KING on Thursday, 02/4/2016 @ 00:21am

KING,

I had voted for Procol Harum when they had first appeared on the nomination ballot back in October, 2012. Procol Harum would be a great nominee to represent early prog during the upcoming 50th anniversary of the "Summer Of Love." My favorite song by Procol Harum is 'Grand Hotel,' followed closely by the live symphonic version of 'Conquistador' and 'A Whiter Shade Of Pale.'

Posted by Enigmaticus on Thursday, 02/4/2016 @ 08:32am

I'm hoping Procol Harum receives a nomination in 2016. Many of the great musicians are dying out recently in their late 60's and early 70's. YES had their chance and could not get voted in last few years. Time to give Moody Blues and Procol Harum a chance. Moody Blues gets on the ballot and they will be inducted. Game, Set, and Match. A Whiter Shade Of Pale was such a Classic song that should help Procol Harum with a Nomination. KING

Posted by KING on Thursday, 02/11/2016 @ 22:15pm

Personally, I really hope they *don't* get inducted as I know what the inevitable consequence would be! Interesting that nobody born before 1945 is listed on this site. A much more deserving inductee would be the great Neil Sedaka who influenced far more people than the Beastie Boys and Stevie Ray Vaughn put together.

Posted by Matthew Fisher on Saturday, 03/26/2016 @ 10:36am

Neil Sedaka over the Beastie Boys and SRV, hahahahaha, no.

Posted by Gassman on Saturday, 03/26/2016 @ 20:00pm

Since we are now approaching the 50th anniversary of the birth of "progressive rock," I think that the time has definitely arrived for us to recognize their co-founders: The Moody Blues and Procol Harum.

Both of these bands were influential, innovative and helped rock music to move forward, rather than staying stagnant.

Posted by Enigmaticus on Friday, 12/23/2016 @ 13:16pm

KING,

Yes, artists of the progressive rock genre have definitely had problems being inducted into the Rock & Roll Hall Of Fame. However, since Rush had been inducted in 2013, the Rock Hall has nominated Yes three times and will finally induct Yes into the Rock & Roll Hall Of Fame in 2017.

However, inducting just one major "progressive rock" artist from 1996 (Pink Floyd) until 2010 (Genesis) had created this backlog. For a genre that is extremely important, influential, relevant, popular and is rapidly nearing it's 50 year anniversary, this is hardly acceptable. But the Rock & Roll Hall Of Fame is a private organization and are entitled to do what they want. However, the economics of inducting artists of the aforementioned genre probably would help to increase their coffers.

In my honest opinion, Procol Harum and The Moody Blues definitely deserve inductions for being the co-founders of "prog."

Posted by Enigmaticus on Wednesday, 12/28/2016 @ 14:48pm

Repent Walpurgis and Whiter Shade invented a form of rock that In Held Twas In I further developed.This in not merely influential but groundbreaking.

Posted by John on Sunday, 01/1/2017 @ 15:21pm

John,

Yes I do agree that all of the co-founders of "progressive rock" and "art rock" definitely deserve to be renominated and inducted into the Rock & Roll Hall Of Fame in 2018. Of course, I would definitely support Procol Harum's induction, as well as that of The Moody Blues

Posted by Enigmaticus on Sunday, 01/1/2017 @ 17:40pm

Procol Harum has been previously nominated for induction into the Rock & Roll Hall Of Fame in 2012. Will they receive another long overdue nomination and induction later this year?

Posted by Enigmaticus on Sunday, 07/9/2017 @ 11:16am

I certainly think that Procol Harum will receive their second nomination for induction into the Rock & Roll Hall Of Fame later this year. What, do you think?

Posted by Enigmaticus on Sunday, 07/23/2017 @ 03:40am

Unfortunately, I have not written extensively about Procol Harum, either.

My first posting about Procol Harum was actually much later, than I had thought:

I had voted for them last year. Do I think that they deserve to be inducted? Absolutely.

Did they really precede The Moody Blues as a co-founder of Progressive rock?

Or did they more or less, invent this genre at about the same time as others, namely Jefferson Airplane and The Moody Blues?

Posted by Enigmaticus on Friday, 11.29.13 @ 07:45am

Posted by Enigmaticus on Tuesday, 09/26/2017 @ 14:15pm

YES!!!

Posted by DIAMOND on Monday, 03/12/2018 @ 20:57pm

Procol Harum SHOULD be the Prog group on the 2018-2019 nomination cycle. Long overdue and many of the members are still living. Some of the greatest songs ever recorded...Crucifiction Lane, Pandora's Box, Hamburg, Whiter Shade Of Pale. Mesmerizing music. KING

Posted by KING on Monday, 03/12/2018 @ 23:36pm

Procol Harum was previously nominated in 2013, and has not been considered since then.
Hope this is corrected and they are nominated again.
They deserve induction in the Hall.
With the well deserved Moody Blues inducted, Procol Harum and Jethro Tull are next on the list.

Posted by Mark on Tuesday, 03/13/2018 @ 10:35am

In the past two years, in my honest opinion, the two biggest events for “prog” have been the induction of Yes into the Rock Hall, by Alex Lifeson and Geddy Lee Of Rush in 2017 and of course, the upcoming induction of founding fathers, The Moody Blues in April, 2018. So, how well do these events bode for the re-nomination of Procol Harum later this year?

Posted by Enigmaticus on Tuesday, 03/13/2018 @ 10:56am

KING,

It is entirely possible that Procol Harum will reappear on the Rock Hall Nomination ballot later this year. However, they may have quite a bit of competition with Jethro Tull and Duran Duran, two assured vote getters. Of course, if the Rock Hall decides to pit The Zombies against them, it could be quite interesting. Personally, I think that Procol Harum could get in, now that fellow prog co-founder, The Moody Blues, have finally been inducted and we know that they will get votes from the older baby boomers, as well.

Posted by Enigmaticus on Sunday, 04/15/2018 @ 22:49pm

I have a differing opinion. Inducting ‘A Whiter Shade Of Pale’ as a single may actually help Procol Harum in the long run. In my honest opinion, the reason why Procol Harum did not get inducted in 2013 has a great deal with their competition: Rush. Unfortunately, they have not yet received a second nomination. I do not think that they have a chance for induction in 2019, but 2020 may be a different story. According to the RIAA, Procol Harum only has one gold album in the U.S., but so also does King Crimson.

Since The Moody Blues have now been inducted, the Rock Hall may decide to go with an artist similar to The Moody Blues. What helps Procol Harum is that the “holy trinity” of prog (Rush, Yes and The Moody Blues) have finally been
inducted. What hurts them is their unfamiliarity with much of the voting populace. However, later this year, Procol Harum will receive competition from Jethro Tull and Duran Duran, two bands which a lot of people will want to see inducted. Next year, the competition will not be so severe, with Supertramp as a likely competitor.

Well, what do you think?

Posted by Enigmaticus on Thursday, 05/10/2018 @ 10:00am

I’m still hoping for PH to get in, and it’s pretty likely to happen in 2021 after JT (2019) and ELP (2020); they would be on the same class with Foo Fighters and Jay-Z three years from now.

Posted by The Dude on Thursday, 05/10/2018 @ 11:12am

I still think that Procol Harum definitely stands a chance of being inducted, even though ‘A Whiter Shade Of Pale’ has been inducted under the new Singles Category. I think that 2020 will be the year of their induction, however.

What do you, think?

Posted by Enigmaticus on Tuesday, 08/21/2018 @ 12:31pm

@ Enig

I think they’ll get an induction within a couple of years from now. Steven Van Zandt did stated that they’re trying to pick some of the names on the singles category, including the late Link Wray.

Posted by The Dude on Tuesday, 08/21/2018 @ 12:49pm

The Dude,

Thank you. I think that the following “prog” bands will be inducted consequently:

2019- Jethro Tull and Duran Duran
2020- Procol Harum and Supertramp
2021- King Crimson and Roxy Music
2022- Kansas and Kraftwerk
2023- Dream Theater
2024- Mastodon
2025- ELP


Will Styx be inducted?

Will Alan Parsons Project?

Will Asia?

Posted by Enigmaticus on Wednesday, 08/22/2018 @ 07:13am

Maybe Styx and Alan Parsons Project have a chance. I don't see Asia happening at all.

Posted by Greg F. on Wednesday, 08/22/2018 @ 18:36pm

Greg F.,

Yes, I would agree that Asia is an unlikely inductee, until ELP receives a nomination and induction. Which we know may be extremely difficult.

Posted by Enigmaticus on Friday, 08/24/2018 @ 09:49am

I have been so busy with work lately, that I have been unable to pick up the next issues of prog at the bookstore, instead I have to order PROG Magazine from the Publisher in the U.K. In case you did not know, I have attempted to purchase copies of every issue of PROG, with the exception of the debut issue (which I have never seen). Unfortunately, some magazine distributors have stopped carrying PROG Magazine completely, so the availability of issues has diminished accordingly. So, why do I mention this? Because one of the more recent issues of PROG, issue 87, pp. 92- 97 features an interview with Gary Brooker, one of the co-founders of Procol Harum.

Posted by Enigmaticus on Tuesday, 08/28/2018 @ 10:07am

ENIG
I'm curious if you have a list of your Top 5 Procol Harum songs. I have believed Brooker & Company were the Masters. Steve Winwood & the Traffic guys excellent as well. Hoping this is Procol Harum year for Induction. I like Homburg maybe the best #1. A Whiter Shade of Pale #2. Conquistador #3. So many great songs.KING

Posted by KING on Wednesday, 08/29/2018 @ 07:18am

KING,

It is great to hear from you again.

Wow, listing my favorite Procol Harum songs is a daunting task, since I have not really heard that many latter period Procol Harum recordings, I will concentrate on the earlier recordings.

I will randomly list 5 songs however, in no particular order.

5. A Salty Dog
4. Shine On Brightly
3. Grand Hotel
2. A Whiter Shade Of Pale
1. Conquistador

Posted by Enigmaticus on Wednesday, 08/29/2018 @ 10:24am

I posted here in 2009 and nearly 10 years later still no HoF for this great band. They are still performing - coming to the US early in 2019. And a new CD Novum last year celebrating their 50 years in the business. Gary Brooker just given a Lifetime Achievement Award in London this week. Oh check out the website www.procolharum.com. Which other artistie has a 7000 page website? they are international and still top quality. As I said before many HoF inductees are people I have never heard of, while A Whiter Shade of Pale is Procol and known worldwide and have performed pretty well everywhere. What is strange is that in the late 60s they were adopted in the US and toured several times there before touring in the UK. Add in the time as The Paramounts you are talking some 55 years of excellent music with many important connections and influences.

Posted by Dr Charles Allison on Sunday, 09/16/2018 @ 10:16am

There was a time when the mention of PH evoked a feeling of reverence. Many people at the time considered them to be amongst the most pre-eminent bands of the their time. They had a sense of regality about them, but not in a snobbish and pretentious way. Their music was regarded simply to be of the highest quality. I remember that feeling being pervasive, whether on campuses, in the factories, or in the streets. With the passing of time and the profusion of musical groups, people have begun to forget their greatness. Having them in the R&R H of F would certainly rectify the wrongs of not having them there, but it would lend a significant touch of class and distinction to the Hall. I believe they truly are one of the most deserving groups that deserve to be there. I am sure that all the musical greats would agree.

Posted by salty dog on Friday, 09/21/2018 @ 21:51pm

Salty Dog,

Back in October 2012, I had voted for two out of the four “prog” bands which had been on the ballot: Rush and Procol Harum. Of course, the members of Rush would definitely support Procol Harum’s induction into the Rock & Roll Hall Of Fame. If Procol Harum does appear on this year’s Rock Hall ballot, then they will most probably be facing stiff competition with Duran Duran and Jethro Tull. However in 2020, I think that they have a much greater chance of being inducted in that year. If the Rock Hall decides to raise the inductees to more than 5, then Procol Harum could conceivably be inducted in 2019. Unfortunately, most Americans are only familiar with the song, ‘A Whiter Shade Of Pale,’ which had been inducted as a single into the Rock Hall earlier this year. Of course, the live version of ‘Conquistador,’ may also be know, as well.

Posted by Enigmaticus on Saturday, 09/22/2018 @ 12:08pm

Salty Dog,

Back in October 2012, I had voted for two out of the four “prog” bands which had been on the ballot: Rush and Procol Harum. Of course, the members of Rush would definitely support Procol Harum’s induction into the Rock & Roll Hall Of Fame. If Procol Harum does appear on this year’s Rock Hall ballot, then they will most probably be facing stiff competition with Duran Duran and Jethro Tull. However in 2020, I think that they have a much greater chance of being inducted in that year. If the Rock Hall decides to raise the inductees to more than 5, then Procol Harum could conceivably be inducted in 2019. Unfortunately, most Americans are only familiar with the song, ‘A Whiter Shade Of Pale,’ which had been inducted as a single into the Rock Hall’s New Singles category earlier this year. Of course, the live version of ‘Conquistador,’ may also be known, as well.

As far as I am concerned, I am much more familiar with more of Procol Harum’s catalog, as well. I had purchased a best of Procol Harum compilation over 30 years ago. Afterwards, I had purchased “Procol Harum,” “Shine On Brightly,” “A Salty Dog” and “Grand Hotel.”

Posted by Enigmaticus on Saturday, 09/22/2018 @ 12:53pm

Perhaps even more baffling is the exclusion of Procol Harum. Procol Harum is one of the co-founders of “prog.” Yes, I know that ‘A Whiter Shade Of Pale,’ had been inducted in the Singles Category earlier this year, but Procol Harum’s lack of a re-nomination in almost indefensible. In addition to The Moody Blues and Jefferson Airplane, Procol Harum had been a nascent influence on Rush. Oh by the way, if Procol Harum had been on this list; they would have probably been inducted. Please listen to Steven Van Zandt and nominate Procol Harum! Thank you.

Posted by Enigmaticus on Tuesday, 10/16/2018 @ 10:08am

Perhaps even more baffling is the exclusion of Procol Harum. Procol Harum is one of the co-founders of “prog.” Yes, I know that ‘A Whiter Shade Of Pale,’ had been inducted in the Singles Category earlier this year, but Procol Harum’s lack of a re-nomination in almost indefensible. In addition to The Moody Blues and Jefferson Airplane, Procol Harum had been a nascent influence on Rush. Oh by the way, if Procol Harum had been on this list; they would have probably been inducted. Please listen to Steven Van Zandt and re-nominate Procol Harum! Thank you.

Posted by Enigmaticus on Tuesday, 10/16/2018 @ 10:30am

Procol Harum definitely should be in the HOF.
As performers
The singles category is not sufficient.

Posted by Mark on Tuesday, 10/16/2018 @ 14:46pm

Mark,

I agree completely. Hopefully, Procol Harum will receive another nomination next year.

Posted by Enigmaticus on Saturday, 12/1/2018 @ 08:57am

Although Jethro Tull and Duran Duran have not yet been nominated, I still think that Procol Harum could receive a re-nomination later this year. Procol Harum is certainly a great deal more than a ‘Whiter Shade Of Pale.’

What helps Procol Harum are the previous inductions of the “holy trinity” of prog (Rush, Yes and The Moody Blues). What hurts them is the general populace’s unfamiliarity with their extensive body of work.

Well, what do you think?

Posted by Enigmaticus on Thursday, 01/10/2019 @ 09:26am

The inductions of Roxy Music, the Zombies and even Radiohead opened more doors for Procol Harum. They’re Brits, they have some/a lot of prog influences, and one of them was around during the 60’s.

Posted by The Dude on Thursday, 01/10/2019 @ 09:41am

Procol Harum might be the next Chaka Khan or The Zombies. I could see PH receiving nominations next few years. There's something brilliant and sophisticated about their music. Like dressing up for a night at the opera and theatre. There's so many great songs in their collection. Crucifiction Lane, Homburg, Pandora's Box, Simple Sister, Whiter Shade Of Pale etc. With The Zombies now inducted, I think Procol Harum and Steve Winwood (Solo) will be next in line for induction. Procol Harum would receive votes from Rush, The Zombies, Yes, and several recently inducted groups. I like their chances of nomination and induction in 2019-2020 cycle. KING

Posted by KING on Thursday, 01/10/2019 @ 09:55am

KING,

I think that Procol Harum certainly deserves another Rock & Roll Hall Of Fame nomination, do you not?

Of course, since they had first been nominated, the Rock Hall playing field has certainly changed.

What helps them are the recent inductions of the “holy trinity of prog,” (Rush, Yes and The Moody Blues), in addition to the recent inductions of Roxy Music and The Zombies.

What hurts them are their unfamiliarity among the general populace. Outside of ‘A Whiter Shade Of Pale’ and ‘Conquistador,’ many voters are not that familiar with their work.

Even so, the Rock Hall had given The Zombies several nominations before they had been inducted. We could place them on the ballot again and see how well they happen to do.

Well, what do you think?

Posted by Enigmaticus on Sunday, 04/7/2019 @ 10:51am

ENIG
Thanks for the kind words on Procol Harum. They are easily 1 of my FAV bands of all time. I can't understand why Procol Harum is still on the outside of the RRHOF fence. A Whiter Shade Of Pale is 1 of the greatest 60's songs and maybe of all time. It has been inducted in the Singles category. The soaring beauty of Homburg or the brilliance of Conquistador shows Procol Harum can create wonderful compositions. I'm a big fan of Pandora's Box too. They can show their rockish side in straight ahead numbers like Simple Sister and Whiskey Train. Procol Harum still continues today with Brooker leading the band. It's difficult to understand why they haven't been inducted. Little Steven has been a good advocate for them and they have been nominated before. They have many of the important criteria checked off: Influence, Innovation, Longevity, Musical Excellence, etc. Procol Harum has always been about the music and not pounding their chests about their greatness or talent...Or extremely vocal about being passed over for the RRHOF. I believe that will change as many of the past or present members would be in their 60's or 70's. A living induction is better than the alternative. Trower has also been snubbed in his excellent solo work after leaving Procol Harum. We should treasure their music as gifted art when today's music is moving more towards auto-tuned voices, intense sampling, and covers/features of other artists. I agree with you that I will more likely gravitate to artists or groups that show instrumental proficiency and intelligent, thoughtful lyrics. Procol Harum hasn't gained much traction here on FRL in the Artist Of The Month or when I nominated a few of their songs. They pick up a few votes. Hopefully, Procol Harum and Duran Duran receive a nomination and induction in 2020, 2021, 2022. Music Justice would be reached and fulfilled. KING 👑

Posted by KING on Sunday, 04/7/2019 @ 11:37am

KING,

You are certainly very welcome. Considering the voting bloc formed from the recent inductions of the “heavy hitters” of prog , i.e. the “holy trinity” of prog (Rush, Yes and The Moody Blues) and of course, Genesis and Pink Floyd before them, plus Traffic, The Zombies, Roxy Music and perhaps even Radiohead, Procol Harum should really have almost no difficulty in receiving another nomination, nor should Duran Duran, nor Jethro Tull. Of course, when Procol Harum had first appeared on the nomination ballot, they had Rush as their main competition; now they will have the votes of Rush’s membership, in addition to most probably the other members of the “holy trinity” of prog (Yes and The Moody Blues). This opens a pretty wide lane for Procol Harum to receive another nomination and perhaps an induction.

My favorite Procol Harum studio album is actually “Grand Hotel,” although I also like their numerous compilations, in addition to “Shine On Brightly,” “A Salty Dog” and the U.S. version of “Procol Harum.”

Well, what do you think?

Posted by Enigmaticus on Monday, 04/8/2019 @ 10:15am

Wow,

It has been over a year since I had posted anything on the Procol Harum page.

KING,

Since Procol Harum is one of your favorite musical artists, please make a case for why you think that Procol Harum deserves an induction into the Rock & Roll Hall Of Fame. Thank you.

Well, what do you think?

Posted by Enigmaticus on Saturday, 06/20/2020 @ 14:46pm

ENIG
I think Procol Harum is deserving RRHOF for several reasons.
1. A Whiter Shade Of Pale is a landmark song. Sold millions over 10 million and 1 of the best of the 1960's.
2. Longevity-Procol Harum still kicking in 2020. That's over 50+ years. Sure they had some break time in the 1980's. Brooker still in good voice.
3. Procol Harum with Moody Blues are at the beginning of 1960's progressive rock music. That's influence and innovation. The RRHOF likes to induct groups who were early and important in a genre.
4. Procol Harum plenty of Classic Songs. A Whiter Shade Of Pale, Conquistador, Homburg, Salty Dog etc. Shows they weren't just 1 hit wonder A Whiter Shade Of Pale.
5. The right support. Steven Van Zandt is in their corner and wants to see them inducted. Probably a few of The Zombies supporters too.
KING

Posted by KING on Saturday, 06/20/2020 @ 17:18pm

Music can be divided into before Procol Harum (BPH) and after Procol Harum (APH) They changed the possibilites of music forever. Procol Harum has to be inducted RRHOF if 1 considers influence, innovation, longevity, musical excellence, etc. A Whiter Shade Of Pale, Conquistador, Crucifiction Lane, Homburg, Simple Sister, etc. Classic Songs! KING

Posted by KING on Wednesday, 07/15/2020 @ 15:01pm

KING, Dr. Charles Allison, Mark, The Dude and salty dog,

Fifty three years ago, something amazing had happened. Rock groups had decided to incorporate new influences into their music. Whether or not, this revolution was sparked by the ingestion of L.S.D. Is entirely speculative.

Procol Harum had released a hit single, 'A Whiter Shade Of Pale,' based upon a work by Johann Sebastian Bach, much to the chagrin of critics who had felt that this incorporation of Baroque, Classical and Romantic styles was a betrayal to the roots of rock & roll. After all, did not Chuck Berry sing a song entitled, 'Roll Over Beethoven?'

However, "progressive rock" was born, and regardless of whether or not, the critics wanted to wish it away; it was here to stay. At around the same time, The Moody Blues had been working on their stage show, Grace Slick had joined Jefferson Airplane, The Beatles were recording "Sergeant Pepper's Lonely Heart's Club Band," Frank Zappa and The Mothers Of Invention were doing their thing and The Nice was just starting out, so there was a great deal of musical innovation occurring at this time.

Even so, Procol Harum was constantly innovating. Gary Brooker had that remarkable soulful voice, Robin Trower's guitar work was phenomenal, Keith Reid's surrealistic lyrics were mind expanding and Matthew Fisher's Hammond Organ was ethereal.

Procol Harum had been nominated for induction into the Rock & Roll Hall Of Fame back in October, 2012; this was only 20 years later than when they were first eligible. In my honest opinion, Procol Harum does indeed deserve induction for writing so many great songs and for having the chutzpah to do what they wanted to do, as such, their work was revolutionary and deserves to be acknowledged accordingly. Of course, out of the 15 nominees for induction in that year, I had chosen the following 5 artists: Rush, Heart, Donna Summer, Randy Newman and Procol Harum.

You are certainly very welcome. Considering the voting bloc formed from the recent inductions of the "heavy hitters" of prog , i.e. the "holy trinity" of prog (Rush, Yes and The Moody Blues) and of course, Genesis and Pink Floyd before them, plus Traffic, The Zombies, Roxy Music and perhaps even Radiohead, Procol Harum should really have almost no difficulty in receiving another nomination, nor should Duran Duran, nor Jethro Tull. Of course, when Procol Harum had first appeared on the nomination ballot, they had Rush as their main competition; now they will have the votes of Rush's membership, in addition to most probably the other members of the "holy trinity" of prog (Yes and The Moody Blues). This opens a pretty wide lane for Procol Harum to receive another nomination and perhaps an induction.

My favorite Procol Harum studio album is actually "Grand Hotel," although I also like their numerous compilations, in addition to "Shine On Brightly," "A Salty Dog" and the U.S. version of "Procol Harum."



2021- Jethro Tull and Duran Duran
2022- Procol Harum and Supertramp
2023- King Crimson and Roxy Music
2024- Kansas and Kraftwerk
2026- Dream Theater
2028- Mastodon
2029- ELP

Well, what do you think?

Posted by Enigmaticus on Sunday, 09/13/2020 @ 06:12am

KING, Dr. Charles Allison, Mark, The Dude and salty dog,

Fifty three years ago, something amazing had happened. Rock groups had decided to incorporate new influences into their music. Whether or not, this revolution was sparked by the ingestion of L.S.D. Is entirely speculative.

Procol Harum had released a hit single, 'A Whiter Shade Of Pale,' based upon a work by Johann Sebastian Bach, much to the chagrin of critics who had felt that this incorporation of Baroque, Classical and Romantic styles was a betrayal to the roots of rock & roll. After all, did not Chuck Berry sing a song entitled, 'Roll Over Beethoven?'

However, "progressive rock" was born, and regardless of whether or not, the critics wanted to wish it away; it was here to stay. The year prior, The Moody Blues had been working on their stage show, Grace Slick had joined Jefferson Airplane, The Beatles were recording "Sergeant Pepper's Lonely Heart's Club Band," Frank Zappa and The Mothers Of Invention were doing their thing and The Nice was just starting out, so there was a great deal of musical innovation occurring at this time.

Even so, Procol Harum was constantly innovating. Gary Brooker had that remarkable soulful voice, Robin Trower's guitar work was phenomenal, Keith Reid's surrealistic lyrics were mind expanding and Matthew Fisher's Hammond Organ was ethereal.

Procol Harum had been nominated for induction into the Rock & Roll Hall Of Fame back in October, 2012; this was only 20 years later than when they were first eligible. In my honest opinion, Procol Harum does indeed deserve induction for writing so many great songs and for having the chutzpah to do what they wanted to do, as such, their work was revolutionary and deserves to be acknowledged accordingly. Of course, out of the 15 nominees for induction in that year, I had chosen the following 5 artists: Rush, Heart, Donna Summer, Randy Newman and Procol Harum.

You are certainly very welcome. Considering the voting bloc formed from the recent inductions of the "heavy hitters" of prog , i.e. the "holy trinity" of prog (Rush, Yes and The Moody Blues) and of course, Genesis and Pink Floyd before them, plus Traffic, The Zombies, Roxy Music and perhaps even Radiohead, Procol Harum should really have almost no difficulty in receiving another nomination, nor should Duran Duran, nor Jethro Tull. Of course, when Procol Harum had first appeared on the nomination ballot, they had Rush as their main competition; now they will have the votes of Rush's membership, in addition to most probably the other members of the "holy trinity" of prog (Yes and The Moody Blues). This opens a pretty wide lane for Procol Harum to receive another nomination and perhaps an induction.

My favorite Procol Harum studio album is actually "Grand Hotel," although I also like their numerous compilations, in addition to "Shine On Brightly," "A Salty Dog" and the U.S. version of "Procol Harum."

Here are my listing of possible Prog inductions over the next several years:

2021- Jethro Tull and Duran Duran
2022- Procol Harum and Supertramp
2023- King Crimson and Kraftwerk
2024- Kansas and Styx
2026- Dream Theater
2028- Mastodon
2029- ELP

Well, what do you think?

Posted by Enigmaticus on Sunday, 09/13/2020 @ 07:13am

KING, Dr. Charles Allison, Mark, The Dude and salty dog,

Fifty three years ago, something amazing had happened. Rock groups had decided to incorporate new influences into their music. Whether or not, this revolution was sparked by the ingestion of L.S.D. Is entirely speculative.

Procol Harum had released a hit single, 'A Whiter Shade Of Pale,' based upon a work by Johann Sebastian Bach, much to the chagrin of critics who had felt that this incorporation of Baroque, Classical and Romantic styles was a betrayal to the roots of rock & roll. After all, did not Chuck Berry sing a song entitled, 'Roll Over Beethoven?'

However, "progressive rock" was born, and regardless of whether or not, the critics wanted to wish it away; it was here to stay. The year prior, The Moody Blues had been working on their stage show, Grace Slick had joined Jefferson Airplane, The Beatles were recording "Sergeant Pepper's Lonely Heart's Club Band," Frank Zappa and The Mothers Of Invention were doing their thing and The Nice was just starting out, so there was a great deal of musical innovation occurring at this time.

Even so, Procol Harum was constantly innovating. Gary Brooker had that remarkable soulful voice, Robin Trower's guitar work was phenomenal, Keith Reid's surrealistic lyrics were mind expanding and Matthew Fisher's Hammond Organ was ethereal.

Procol Harum had been nominated for induction into the Rock & Roll Hall Of Fame back in October, 2012; this was only 20 years later than when they were first eligible. In my honest opinion, Procol Harum does indeed deserve induction for writing so many great songs and for having the chutzpah to do what they wanted to do, as such, their work was revolutionary and deserves to be acknowledged accordingly. Of course, out of the 15 nominees for induction in that year, I had chosen the following 5 artists: Rush, Heart, Donna Summer, Randy Newman and Procol Harum.

You are certainly very welcome. Considering the voting bloc formed from the recent inductions of the "heavy hitters" of prog , i.e. the "holy trinity" of prog (Rush, Yes and The Moody Blues) and of course, Genesis and Pink Floyd before them, plus Traffic, The Zombies, Roxy Music and perhaps even Radiohead, Procol Harum should really have almost no difficulty in receiving another nomination, nor should Duran Duran, nor Jethro Tull. Of course, when Procol Harum had first appeared on the nomination ballot, they had Rush as their main competition; now they will have the votes of Rush's membership, in addition to most probably the other members of the "holy trinity" of prog (Yes and The Moody Blues). This opens a pretty wide lane for Procol Harum to receive another nomination and perhaps an induction.

My favorite Procol Harum studio album is actually "Grand Hotel," although I also like their numerous compilations, in addition to "Shine On Brightly," "A Salty Dog" and the U.S. version of "Procol Harum."

Here is my listing of possible Prog inductions over the next several years:

2021- Jethro Tull and Duran Duran
2022- Procol Harum and Supertramp
2023- King Crimson and Kraftwerk
2024- Kansas and Styx
2026- Dream Theater
2028- Mastodon
2029- ELP

Well, what do you think?

Posted by Enigmaticus on Sunday, 09/13/2020 @ 07:14am

I think if Kansas, Styx and ELP are inducted then ELP should go in 5 years before Kansas and Styx, not Kansas and Styx going in 5 years before ELP

Posted by joker on Sunday, 09/13/2020 @ 11:59am

Whaling Stories is the most epic RnR song ever made. How can you not include a band that makes art like that!?

Posted by Jeopcon on Sunday, 09/13/2020 @ 15:47pm

KING, Dr. Charles Allison, Mark, The Dude and salty dog,

Fifty three years ago, something amazing had happened. Rock groups had decided to incorporate new influences into their music. Whether or not, this revolution was sparked by the ingestion of L.S.D. Is entirely speculative.

Procol Harum had released a hit single, 'A Whiter Shade Of Pale,' based upon a work by Johann Sebastian Bach, much to the chagrin of critics who had felt that this incorporation of Baroque, Classical and Romantic styles was a betrayal to the roots of rock & roll. After all, did not Chuck Berry sing a song entitled, 'Roll Over Beethoven?'

However, "progressive rock" was born, and regardless of whether or not, the critics wanted to wish it away; it was here to stay. The year prior, The Moody Blues had been working on their stage show, Grace Slick had joined Jefferson Airplane, The Beatles were recording "Sergeant Pepper's Lonely Heart's Club Band," Frank Zappa and The Mothers Of Invention were doing their thing and The Nice was just starting out, so there was a great deal of musical innovation occurring at this time.

Even so, Procol Harum was constantly innovating. Gary Brooker had that remarkable soulful voice, Robin Trower's guitar work was phenomenal, Keith Reid's surrealistic lyrics were mind expanding and Matthew Fisher's Hammond Organ was ethereal.

Procol Harum had been nominated for induction into the Rock & Roll Hall Of Fame back in October, 2012; this was only 20 years later than when they were first eligible. In my honest opinion, Procol Harum does indeed deserve induction for writing so many great songs and for having the chutzpah to do what they wanted to do, as such, their work was revolutionary and deserves to be acknowledged accordingly. Of course, out of the 15 nominees for induction in that year, I had chosen the following 5 artists: Rush, Heart, Donna Summer, Randy Newman and Procol Harum.

You are certainly very welcome. Considering the voting bloc formed from the recent inductions of the "heavy hitters" of prog , i.e. the "holy trinity" of prog (Rush, Yes and The Moody Blues) and of course, Genesis and Pink Floyd before them, plus Traffic, The Zombies, Roxy Music and perhaps even Radiohead, Procol Harum should really have almost no difficulty in receiving another nomination, nor should Duran Duran, nor Jethro Tull. Of course, when Procol Harum had first appeared on the nomination ballot, they had Rush as their main competition; now they will have the votes of Rush's membership, in addition to most probably the other members of the "holy trinity" of prog (Yes and The Moody Blues). This opens a pretty wide lane for Procol Harum to receive another nomination and perhaps an induction.

My favorite Procol Harum studio album is actually "Grand Hotel," although I also like their numerous compilations, in addition to "Shine On Brightly," "A Salty Dog" and the U.S. version of "Procol Harum."

Here is my listing of possible Prog inductions over the next several years:

2021- Jethro Tull and Duran Duran
2022- Procol Harum and Supertramp
2023- King Crimson and Kraftwerk
2024- Kansas and Styx
2026- Dream Theater
2028- Mastodon
2029- ELP

Well, what do you think?

Posted by Enigmaticus on Sunday, 10/11/2020 @ 15:40pm

Rest in Peace Alan Cartwright, 1945-2021.

Posted by Joe on Tuesday, 03/9/2021 @ 22:30pm

Procol Harum songs have changed my life since I was 16 and Whiter shade of pale. They should have been inducted long ago. Rip Gary Brooker. With Brookers death this should happen very soon not 2028. Thanks to Their music I found an interest in Baroque and classical music whenI was young and attended my first Orchrstra in 2020. Please everyone should send emails or texts to Rock and Roll HALL of Fame. They should be I introduced by JETHRO TULL.

Posted by David Webster on Tuesday, 02/22/2022 @ 12:16pm

A RIP to a KING FAV Gary Brooker Procol Harum. Brilliant pianist and vocalist for 55 years. I'm still amazed Procol Harum has not been inducted into the Rock & Roll Hall Of Fame. Unfortunately, this has happened to several musicians lately as they have passed. Still waiting to be enshrined. Condolences to Gary Brooker's friends and family and to Procol Harum the group and their many fans across the world. Will definitely play some Conquistador and Simple Sister in honor of a legendary musician. Definitely will be missed. KING

Posted by KING on Tuesday, 02/22/2022 @ 15:40pm

Rest in Peace Gary Brooker; Procol Harum singer, pianist and songwriter, 1945-2022.

Posted by Joe S. on Wednesday, 02/23/2022 @ 01:17am

My most sincere condolences to the family and friends of the late, great Gary Brooker on his unfortunate recent passing. Gary Brooker will most assuredly be missed.

Well, what do you think?

Posted by Enigmaticus on Wednesday, 02/23/2022 @ 04:55am

The recent unfortunate passing of the late, great Gary Brooker should lead to another nomination for Procol Harum into the Rock & Roll Hall Of Fame.

KING, Dr. Charles Allison, Mark, The Dude and salty dog,

Almost fifty five years ago, something amazing had happened. Rock groups had decided to incorporate new influences into their music. Whether or not, this revolution was sparked by the ingestion of L.S.D. Is entirely speculative.

Procol Harum had released a hit single, 'A Whiter Shade Of Pale,' based upon a work by Johann Sebastian Bach, much to the chagrin of critics who had felt that this incorporation of Baroque, Classical and Romantic styles was a betrayal to the roots of rock & roll. After all, did not Chuck Berry sing a song entitled, 'Roll Over Beethoven?'

However, "progressive rock" was born, and regardless of whether or not, the critics wanted to wish it away; it was here to stay. The year prior, The Moody Blues had been working on their stage show, Grace Slick had joined Jefferson Airplane, The Beatles were recording "Sergeant Pepper's Lonely Heart's Club Band," Frank Zappa and The Mothers Of Invention were doing their thing and The Nice was just starting out, so there was a great deal of musical innovation occurring at this time.

Even so, Procol Harum was constantly innovating. Gary Brooker had that remarkable soulful voice, Robin Trower's guitar work was phenomenal, Keith Reid's surrealistic lyrics were mind expanding and Matthew Fisher's Hammond Organ was ethereal.

Procol Harum had been nominated for induction into the Rock & Roll Hall Of Fame back in October, 2012; this was only 20 years later than when they were first eligible. In my honest opinion, Procol Harum does indeed deserve induction for writing so many great songs and for having the chutzpah to do what they wanted to do, as such, their work was revolutionary and deserves to be acknowledged accordingly. Of course, out of the 15 nominees for induction in that year, I had chosen the following 5 artists: Rush, Heart, Donna Summer, Randy Newman and Procol Harum.

You are certainly very welcome. Considering the voting bloc formed from the recent inductions of the "heavy hitters" of prog , i.e. the "holy trinity" of prog (Rush, Yes and The Moody Blues) and of course, Genesis and Pink Floyd before them, plus Traffic, The Zombies, Roxy Music and perhaps even Radiohead, Procol Harum should really have almost no difficulty in receiving another nomination, nor should Duran Duran, nor Jethro Tull. Of course, when Procol Harum had first appeared on the nomination ballot, they had Rush as their main competition; now they will have the votes of Rush's membership, in addition to most probably the other members of the "holy trinity" of prog (Yes and The Moody Blues). This opens a pretty wide lane for Procol Harum to receive another nomination and perhaps an induction.

My favorite Procol Harum studio album is actually "Grand Hotel," although I also like their numerous compilations, in addition to "Shine On Brightly," "A Salty Dog" and the U.S. version of "Procol Harum."

Here is my listing of possible Prog inductions over the next several years:

2022- Duran Duran
2023- Procol Harum and Jethro Tull
2024- Kansas and King Crimson
2025- Gentle Giant
2026- Dream Theater
2028- Mastodon
2029- ELP

Well, what do you think?

Posted by Enigmaticus on Wednesday, 02/23/2022 @ 05:13am

February 19th is a bad day for rock stars to die over the span of 42 years Bon Scott (1980) Kelly Groucutt (2009) & now Gary Brooker (2022) may they all RIP! :'(

"Now the current hit by the British group who bombed with their first recording of this song 5 years ago, but this 2nd version is a winner, and all they had to do was add a 52-piece symphony orchestra, and a 24-voice choir, in the Summer of 1967 they had a big hit called A Whiter Shade of Pale, which went to #5, they followed that with another single that never even saw the Hot 100, on the next try a couple of months later with a song called Homburg, they reached #34, but that was their last time on the charts, the single charts, until now, this current hit the one that failed 5 years ago, was rerecorded last November at a concert in Canada, 3,000 people sat in the Jubilee Auditorium in Edmonton, Alberta, and listened to a 5-man English rock group, backed by 76 classical musicians and singers, a best selling album came out of that program, and a hit single came out of the album, a song that didn't make it the first time around, now at #22, and movin' up, Conquistador, by Procol Harum" - Casey Kasem's American Top 40 from July 8th, 1972

8-)

Conquistador (Live at Edmonton, Alberta/1971)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fOb9NWHo7J4

Posted by Rick Vendl II on Thursday, 02/24/2022 @ 17:18pm

RIP Gary Brooker

Posted by Roy on Friday, 02/25/2022 @ 08:31am

To the person posting inre the Moody Blues VS Procol Harum,,Both Bands are ICONIC to Sound and Music,as to the one over the other,read up and get facts straight,,Moody Blues started way befor Procol Harum,,62 or 63,,,Procol 1967,,Moody Blues did have different artists and changes,but still began way before Procol Harum,,,BOTH Bands should have been inducted yrs ago,but as always,people running the show,wanted other genres in their first,regardless of the style of music,the sound,wordless meanings and gibberish only they can understand and still call it music,,,ok,,,,so many Groups deserve to be in there,way before some others,,,,It's all a show and a shame,,what I find lousy is that some of the Artists are now deceased and never got to see the honor,,Moody Blues--Ray Thomas for example,,anyway,no matter what I say,it will never change things,,,just my points of view,,,,,,,,,corruption is everywhere these days,not just in Govt,but music people making bad decisions,,,,

Posted by LR on Friday, 03/3/2023 @ 21:31pm

RIP Keith Reid brilliant lyricist Procol Harum 76. His intelligent, unique words coupled with Procol Harum's outstanding music...It made PH 1 of the great 1960's and early 1970's progressive rock groups. Will miss him and Gary Brooker.
KING

Posted by KING on Friday, 03/31/2023 @ 01:13am

I'm not a voter or a member of the RRHL community
just keep wondering why Procol harum keeps getting overlooked
I guess time has passed them by
but as a eye witness
They were a tremendous live rock group who i fitst saw at the fillmore east and they put on 2 hour plus shows each musician a virtuoso performance
Gary brooker had one of the most incredible voices in Rock thats not being acknowledged Robin Troqer was a guitar maniac in person who had fastest hands around
They didnt per se have top ten hits only very immersive great albums with 7-8 great songs on their first 4-5
Salty dog was a beautifully crafted masterpiece Simple sister should be on Classic ricck rotation for sure
Also i dint know how many dozenz upon dozens if films use whiter shade of pale to clue the beginning of the flower power generation
In one of Gary Brookers last concerts he alluded to the fact that song was the main soundtrack of Hollywood for the 1960s Probably couple creedence songs airplane white rabbit as well
and helped pay for many family events
Anyway the days of great albums is lost
At leat I can ask Alexa play this album or that and be assured of getting 25-40 minutes of great music instead of 1 song at a time as today
Procol harum was released n the end a Rock Group not anymore or less
Nuff said deserve RRHL

Posted by Michael B on Wednesday, 04/10/2024 @ 06:40am

Sorry about my previous spelling mistakes in my post
There was a annoying black square blocking the posting
Anyway Procol Harum were Great !!

Posted by Michael on Wednesday, 04/10/2024 @ 06:45am